⭐ HIGHLIGHTS

IMPORTANT LABOUR JUDGMENTS -2011





Under U.P. ID Act even the probationer or an appointee for a fix period is entitled to the benefit of sec. 6N. Retrenchment compliance is mandatory in these cases too.

Managing Director, Pradeshik Co-operative

Dairy Federation Ltd., Lucknow and Another

vs. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Agra and

Others. 2011 LLR 799 (All. HC)

After lapse of 35 years from

retrenchment, even if it was held illegal,

compensation of Rs. Two Lakh shall serve

the end of justice in place of reinstatement

with back wages.

State of Bihar vs. Gajadhar Singh (Amin) 2011

LLR 830 (Patna HC)

No reinstatement even if there is no

compliance of retrenchment procedure of

paying notice and compensation. Instead

50% back wages as damages would be

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

instead of reinstatement would be proper.

Purvanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd.,

Varanasi and Another vs. State of U.P. and

Others. 2011 LLR 631 (All. HC)

The termination of the service of the

workman was held to be in violation of

S.25-F of the Act, but since his

appointment was not regular, he was held

entitled to compensation only.

Nepal Khichhu Ram vs. Presiding Officer,

Labour Court. LLJ II 2011 P. 80 (P&H HC)

It is the bounden duty of the employer to

produce the service record of the workman

who alleges violation of provisions of

Sec.25-F and 25-G.

Navinsingh Bharodiya vs. State of Madhya

Pradesh. LLJ II 2011 P. 283 (M.P. HC)

Even in the case of violation of sec. 25F

of ID Act or sec. 6N of U.P. ID Act,

compensation / reasonable damages

should be paid instead of reinstatement.

M/s. Areva T & D India Ltd. vs. Presiding

Officer, Labour Court U.P., Allahabad & Ors.

2011 LLR 697 (All. HC)

While calculating 240 days working in

case of daily wage workman, period of

weekly holidays and public holidays are to

be excluded. Since workman did not

qualify for retrenchment benefits, he is not

entitled to any relief under sec. 25H of ID

Act.

Ranjit Natvar Lal Chauhan vs. Morbi Nagar

Palika. 2011 LLR 704 (Guj. HC)

proper.

Deputy Director, Administration Rajya Krishi

Upadan Mandi Parishad, Agra & Anr. vs.

Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Agra and

Another. 2011 LLR 969 (Allahabad HC)

Compensation and not reinstatement

would be proper even when retrenchment

of supervisor on daily basis was not as per

procedure.

State of U.P. and others vs. Presiding Officer,

Labour Court No. 2, Ghaziabad U.P. and

Another. 2011 LLR 973 (Allahabad HC)

When workman worked for 80 days, plea

of infraction of 25F of ID Act can't be

taken. However, since bank clerk cum-

cashier was terminated without notice in

violation of 25G and 25H, compensation of

one lakh in lieu of reinstatement with

back wages would be proper.

Sudha Ratna Singh vs. Union of India and

Others. 2011 (130) FLR 58 (Patna HC)

Retrenchment justified when a

department of the school is shut down. No

prior approval of retrenchment is required

from director of education in case of

unaided school.

Prabhu Dayal Public School & Ors. vs.

Anirudh Singh and Ors. 2011 LLR 1016 (Delhi

HC)

In the absence of any document

pertaining to enquiry on the misconduct of

wilful absence and termination order, such

termination amounts to illegal

50

Business Manager

February 2012

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

retrenchment and reinstatement with back

wages will be justified.

Punjab Agriculture University and Anr. vs.

Presiding Officer, Labour Court and Anr. 2011

LLR 1086 (P&H HC)

Retrenchment effected without

complying the provisions of sec. 9A of the

ID Act would be illegal.

Y. Premlatha vs. Hyderabad Co-operative

Central Trading Society Limited and another.

2011 (130) FLR 1091 (AP HC)

When company failed to prove why

principle of 'last come first go' not

followed, retrenchment would be invalid.

Mahavir Steel Industries (P.) Limited, Pune vs.

Pune Workers Union, Pune and another. 2011

(130) FLR 1103 (Bom. HC)

Retrenchment without adhering to the

mandatory provisions of S.25 is void ab

initio.

Municipal Council vs. Chhotalal & Anr. LLN I

2011 P. 258 (Raj. HC)

Once retrenchment is held to be genuine

and bonafide by complying all statutory

requirements, reinstatement can’t be

ordered.

Vicco Laboratories Limited and Another vs.

Maharashtra General Kamgar Union. 2011

LLR 1178 (Bom. HC)

It is mandatory for the employee to

complete 240 days service in a year to avail

protection under sec. 25F of ID Act.

1. Management of Apparel Export Promotion

Council vs. Surya Prakash. 2011 LLR 1208 (Del.

HC)

2. Dharmender Singh vs. The Presiding Officer,

Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Union

Territory and

Another. 2011 LLR 1215 (P&H

HC)

In case of illegal termination without

retrenchment compensation,

reinstatement without back wages proper.

Board of Secondary Education vs. Rajesh

Nema and Another. 2011 LLR 1280 (MP HC)

Employee who has continued in service

for five years cannot be terminated form

service without complying with the

provisions of section 25(F) of the I.D. Act.

Keru Kisan Rokade vs. Geoffery Manners &

Company Ltd., Nashik. LLN (4) 2010 P. 697

(Bom. HC)

When bankers cheque towards one

month notice and retrenchment

compensation is offered to the employee at

the time of retrenchment, it complies with

the provisions of ID Act.

Sudarshan Rout vs. Commissioner-cum-

Secretary to Govt. of Orissa & Ors. 2011 LLR

477 (Orissa HC)

Retrenchment without following the

principle of "last come first go" held

illegal. Reinstatement without back wages

proper.

Mussoorie Dehradun Development Authority

vs. Shri Rameshwar and Others. 2011 (128)

FLR 1030 (Uttarakhand HC)

Retirement

When the workman retired during the

pendency of the case, compensation and

not reinsatement rightly awarded by

Labour Court.

Krishna Chandra Rout vs. Presiding Officer,

Labour Court, Sambalpur & Three Ors. 2011

LLR 354 (Orissa HC)

In the absence of having practice of not

employing persons till life-time, employee

cannot challenge his retirement at the age

of 58 on the plea that there were no service

rules.

T. Anantha Krishan vs. Management of

Madras Purasawalkam Hindu Janopakara

Saswatha Nidhi or The Permanent General

Benefit Fund Ltd., Chennai and Another. 2011II

LLJ 557 (Madras HC)

Award of wages beyond the age of

retirement is not sustainable.

Mahalaxmi Fibres & Industries Ltd. vs.

Santosh Tiwari & Ors. LLJ II 2011 P. 100 (Jhar.

HC)

When there is a settlement about

retirement age at 60 years, there will be no

significance of Model Standing Orders

providing 58 years as retirement age.

Balmer Lawrie & Co. Ltd., Mumbai & Anr. vs.

Engineering Workers' Association, Mumbai &

Anr. 2011 (II) CLR 787 (Bom. HC)

Settlement

During the operation of settlement when

agreed that no financial demand will be

raised, enhancement of retirement age

will not be tenable.

M/s Kennametal India Ltd. vs. Kennametal

India Employees' Association & Ors. 2011 LLR

584 (Kar. HC)

Bipartite settlement arrived at under

section 18(3) of I.D. Act will not be binding

on the subsequent purchaser of the

factory.

General Sec., Gujarat Audhyogik Kamgar

Sangthan vs. Kalyan Paper & Board Mills &

Anr. 2011 LLR 659 (Guj. HC)

When a settlement has been made by a

Union unrecognised under the

Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions

& Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices

Act, 1971, only those employees will be

entitled to benefits who have been a party

to it.

S.D. Muley and Others vs. Jaihind Industries

and Another. 2011 (129) FLR 929 (Bom. HC)

Business Manager

February 2012

51

Company cannot be said to have

violatated the provisions of ID Act when

acted as per conciliation settlement.

Indian Semlting And Refining Company

Limited vs. Anthony D' Almeida and another.

2011 (130) FLR 958 (Bom. HC)

Settlement signed by the earstwhile

employer with the employees will not be

binding on the subsequent employer who

bought machinery and factory. Since new

purchaser was not party to settlement

employees can't get any benefit from the

new employer on the basis of the settlement.

General Secretary, Gujarat Audyogik Kamgar

Sangthan vs. Kalyan Paper & Board Mills &

Anr. FLR (129) 2011 P. 1067 (Guj. HC)

Settlement executed with the majority

union is binding upon all workmen

including members of minority union and

the settlement will continue to be effective

for specific period till the same is

substituted by another settlement.

Taj Services Ltd. vs. Industrial Tribunal-1

Delhi & Ors. 2011 LLR 1133 (Delhi HC)

Employees who have left services by

opting golden handshake and by receiving

compensation in terms of section 18(1) of

the settlement are not entitled to enhance

compensation given to other employees in

subsequent settlement.

G. Damodaran & Ors. vs. Managing Director,

Hindustan Liver Ltd. LLN (4) 2010 P. 725 (Mad.

HC)

petitioner's establishment employed 100 or

more workmen in the 12 months preceding

the inspection to attract the applicability

of Industrial Employment (Standing

Orders) Act. Thus, there was no basis for

the prosecution to show the Act was

applicable to petitioner's establishment.

Bapineedu Chowdary vs. State of Andhra

Pradesh and Another. 2011-III LLJ 196 (AP HC)

Strike

The doctors, residents, interns, para-

medical staff and any other person

connected with AIIMS can't be allowed to

go on strike. Any such strike is illegal.

Such persons engaging themselves in such

activity would be liable for disciplinary

proceedings and contempt of court.

Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes

Medical Association (Regd.) Delhi vs. Union of

India and Others. 2011 LLR 366 (Del. HC)

During the pendency of conciliation

proceedings it is not open to the unions

and its members to proceed on strike. It

would be an illegal strike.

Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd., Mumbai

vs. Petroleum Workmen's Union Thane & Ors.

2011 III CLR 187 (Bom. HC)

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

Shops &

Establishments

Society imparting education to deaf

community covered as establishment

under Delhi Shops Act will also be covered

under Minimum Wages Act.

Multipurpose Training Centre for the Deaf vs.

Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. 2011 LLR

548 (Del. HC)

Standing Orders

When certified standing orders

providing the age of retirement at 58,

reduction of retirement age from 60 to 58

by the management will not amount in to

change in service conditions.

Sri Achyuta Charan Panda vs. The Managing

Director, Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. 2011 LLR

472 (Orissa HC)

There was no foundation in the

complaint, as there was no statement that

Suspension

In the absence of proof of reporting for

duty after revocation of suspension order,

workman will not be entitled to any salary.

Chaman Lal vs. Presiding Officer, Labour

Court, Patiala. 2011 LLR 577 (P& H HC)

Termination

When employee submitted cogent proof

of his date of birth, his termination on the

ground of providing wrong age would be

illegal.

Shambhu Mishra vs. Airport Authority of

India Ltd. & Ors. 2011 LLR 90 (Del. HC)

Termination without any charge though

discharge simpliciter would still be illegal

retrenchment when conditions precedent

not followed. Reinstatement with 30% back

wages proper.

Cotton Corporation of India Ltd. and Another

vs. State of Rajasthan and Others. 2011 LLR 74

(Raj. HC)

No illegal termination of a temporary

employee due to abolition of his post.

52

Business Manager

February 2012

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

Ahmedabad Municipal Transport Service vs.

Atul Chimanlal Shah. 2011 LLR 194 (Guj. HC)

A temporary employee on a post which is

abolished and is relieved, such action can't

be termed as termination. No

reinstatement in such case.

Ahmedabad Municipal Transport Service vs.

Atul Chimanlal Shah. 2011 LLR 254 (Guj. HC)

Termination of a probationer will be

illegal without enquiry if show cause is

issued.

Jagdish Chand vs. Managing Director,

H.R.T.C. and Others. 2011 LLR 346 (HP HC)

While imposing punishment,

consideration of past records is important.

Termination for unauthorised absence of

18 days improper. Reinstatement without

wages granted.

Veer Chand vs. D.T.C. 2011 (128)

FLR 547 (Del. HC)

Casual or daily rated workers when not

appointed as per rules will not be entitled

to any relief on termination.

Bachsangji Chehraji Thakur & Ors. vs. Deputy

General Manager & Ors. 2011 (I) CLR 862 (Guj.

HC)

Once the termination has been found

void ab-initio, reinstatement with

seniority ought to be granted.

Kirpa Ram vs. Secretary, H.P. State Board and

Others. 2011 LLR 507 (HP HC)

Merely because the insurance company

made good the losses caused to bank by the

abuse of powers by the employee in case of

granting loans against bank lending

norms, removal from service of such

employee can't be set aside.

Sunil Kumar Srivastava vs. Union of India

and Others. 2011 LLR 1036 (All. HC)

One who is offered work on daily wages

is not entitled for any notice or one

month's pay in lieu of notice, while service

terminated.

State of Maharashtra, Sub Divisional Forest

Officer vs. Sadashiv Maroti Doke & Anr. LLN

(3) 2011 P. 124 (Bom. HC)

Regularising juniors and terminating

the services of senior would be in violation

of sec. 25A, 25B, 25F and 25G of ID Act.

Termination has illegal.

Superintendent, Ummed Hospital, Jodhpur vs.

Judge, Industrial Disputes Tribunal and

Labour Court, Jodhpur. 2011 LLR 1115 (Raj. HC)

Trade Union

Derecognition of the union by airlines

management without following the rules

of natural justice is liable to be set aside.

Air Corporation Employees Union vs. Air India

Ltd. 2011 (129) FLR 752 (Delhi HC)

When the employer at the request of the

Union has been deducting the subscription

of the Union while making the payment of

wages, it cannot be stopped since it will be

against the fundamental right granted for

formation of a trade union.

Coimbatore Periyar Districts Dravida,

Panjalai Thozhilalar Munnetra Sangam, rep.

by its Gen. Secretary S. Doraisamy & Ors. vs.

National Textile Corporation Limited,

Coimbatore & Ors. 2011 LLR 1076 (Mad. HC)

Registrar is empowered to give registration

to a union as a multi state union.

Akhil Dadra & Nagar Haveli Kamgar Sangh,

Silvassa, Dadra & Nagar Haveli vs.

Krantikari Kamgar Union & Ors. 2011 III CLR

26 (Bom. HC)

Withdrawal of recognition of a union

will not be interfered by the High Court.

Committee of Management Trimurti Higher

Secondary School, Khushhal, Moradabad vs.

State of U.P. . and others. 2011 LLR 246 (All. HC)

Before de-recognizing the union,

employer must issue show cause notice to

union and afford an opportunity of

hearing.

Air Corporation Employees Union vs. Air India

Ltd. 2011 I CLR 695 (Del. HC)

Although no employer is under an

obligation to offer check-off (collecting

membership fee from members) facility to

the Union but when such a facility has

been extended for 21 years, its withdrawal,

all of a sudden, would be arbitrary.

Rashtriya Colliery Majdoor Congress and

Another vs. South Eastern Coalfields Ltd. and

Others. 2011 (130) FLR 248 (MP HC)

Transfer

Where undertaking transferred from

one employer to other, in the absence of

any specific provision, taking consent of

employee for transferring his services to

new employer does not apply. In such case

employee is not entitled to any

compensation on the ground that he is not

willing to work with new employer.

J.V. Sudhakar vs. Government of A.P. rep. by

its Principal Secretary, Labour Deptt. and Ors.

2011 LLR 43 (A.P. HC)

Conciliation officer has no powers to

stay the transfer orders made by employer.

He can only mediate and not adjudicate the

dispute.

Maharashtra General Kamgar Union, through

its Joint Secretary and Ors. vs. Pix

Transmissions Ltd. & Anr. 2011 I CLR 106

(Bom. HC)

Where Standing Orders restrict transfer

of employees to Bangalore only, transfer of

employees to another state would be

illegal.

Business Manager

February 2012

53

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

M/s. Madura Coats Pvt. Ltd., Rep. by its

Manager vs. The Workmen of M/s. Madura

Coats Pvt. Ltd., Rep. by Madura Coats

Employees' Union. 2011 LLR 81 (Karn. HC)

Transfer of chemical engineer from

Durgapur plant to sales office as sales

manager at Kolkata that too without any

vacancy would be malafide and illegal.

Dipankar Bandopadhyay vs. Durgapur

Chemicals Ltd. & Ors. 2011 LLR 293 (Cal. HC)

Transfer of a Technician Grade II to

another post in the same category cannot

be construed as illegal.

T.N. Mohila and Others vs. U.P. State Electricity

Board and Others. 2011 LLR 834 (All. HC)

Transfer on allegations of misconduct

without putting the employee on notice

and seeking his reply is bad in law.

Madhura Mohan Nayak vs. State of Orissa &

Ors. LLN(2) 2011 P. 613 (Orissa HC)

Transfer from Bhopal to Bhubaneswar

that too on temporary basis needs no

interference.

Dr. H.S. Tripathi vs. National Council for

Teachers Education and Others. 2011 LLR 916

(MP HC)

When bank employee was suspected of

fraud, his transfer instead of putting him

on disciplinary proceedings, would be

illegal and liable to be set aside.

Biplab Das vs. The Chairman, Bangiya

Gramin Vikash Bank & Ors. 2011 LLR 947

(Cal. HC)

Transfer from one company to another

having separate legal entity not

permissible. Transfer on the ground of

indulgence in anti-management activities

cannot be turned into administrative

excegencies.

Sneha Kumar Pradhan vs. Mahanadi

Coalfields Limited and others. 2011 (130) FLR

852 (Orissa HC)

When transfer order affects the service

condition and financial entitlements, then

court can interfere with the order that too

when the transfer was ordered only after

21 days of first transfer.

Kartika Chandra Ray vs. Neelachal Gramya

Bank and Others. 2011 LLR 706 (Orissa HC)

Inconvenience of the employee in

domestic front in view of transfer can't

justify interference with transfer order.

Tapan Kumar Das Purkayastha vs. Hindustan

Paper Corporation Ltd. 2011 LLR 735

(Gauhati HC)

Unfair Labour

Practice

Inviting workers to undergo training to

act as officers through introduction of

promotion scheme by management would

not be unfair labour practice.

Siemens Ltd. Vs. Siemens Employees

Union 2011 (131) FLR 1100 (SC)

Showing workers as on project, but in

fact doing perennial nature of work, would

be unfair labour practice.

Reliance Energy Ltd., Mumbai vs. Yadayya

Giri and Others. 2010 (4) LLN 787 (Bom. HC)

Keeping sweepers and bus body cleaners

as temporary for years together would be

unfair labour practice. Order of making

them permanent proper.

Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation

(Madurai Division-IV) formerly known as Rani

Management Transport Corporation Ltd.),

Dindigul vs. (1) Presiding Officer, Industrial

Tribunal (2) Secretary, Rani Mangammal

Pokkuvarathu Thozhilalar Sangam, Dindigul.

2010 (4) LLN 703 (Mad. HC)

Paying less to daily wagers having

identical nature of duties with permanent,

will amount to unfair labour practice

under ID Act.

Maharashtra Lok Kamgar Sanghatana vs.

Ballarpur Industries Ltd. and another. 2011

(128) FLR 885 (Bom. HC)

If a workman was employed and reemployed

to show that his services were

terminated before 240 days will amounts

to unfair labour practice.

Krishan Lal vs. General Manager, Haryana

Roadways, Rohtak and another. 2011 (128) FLR

752 (P&H HC)

VRS

Under VRS, right of management to

accept or reject the application of any

employee for VRS can’t be questioned.

Chairman and M.D., Indian Overseas Bank &

Ors. vs. Tribhuwan Nath Srivastava. 2011 LLR

225 (S.C.)

Employees relieved under VRS cannot

raise Industrial Dispute under Section 2A

of the ID Act.

Bayer Bio Sciences Pvt. Ltd. vs. Presiding

Officer, Labour Court-I and Others. 2011 (129)

FLR 17 (AP HC)

Once employee makes option for VRS

and is also accepted by the management,

can't be further withdrawn by the

employee.

Anil Nandwani (Mrs.) vs. Food Corporation of

India & Ors. 2011 LLR 518 (Del. HC)

When employee was relieved under VRS,

no disciplinary proceedings could be

initiated against him.

S.V. Vanajakshi vs. TUCS Limited, represented

by its Special Officer, 119, Big Street, Triplicane,

Chennai-5. 2011 (I) LLN 709 (Mad. HC)

Employee has a right to withdraw his

notice of voluntary retirement before

acceptance by the management.

54

Business Manager

February 2012

Mahendra Gajanan Trivedi vs. Bank of India

& Ors. 2011 LLR 1096 (Guj. HC)

Condition of refunding amount received

after VRS by workman is proper in order

to challenge VRS which was accepted

under duress.

Man Singh vs. Maruti Suzuki India Ltd. &

Another. 2011 LLR 1009 (SC)

If an application for voluntary

retirement is not withdrawn before

acceptance, its acceptance by the employer

will be valid.

Siddaiah vs. Management of Mandya

National Paper Mills Ltd., Belagula. 2011 LLR

1267 (Karn. HC)

Withdrawal of application for voluntary

retirement is permissible till the date the

same is to be effected in future.

Balaram Saghan Kshetra Samiti vs. Kantaben

Laljibhai Patel & 2 Ors. 2011 LLR 1251 (Guj. HC)

Workman

Even if the casual workers appointed for

six months on monthly break up to 30

years can’t claim permanency being

original appointment not in terms of the

process envisaged by the rules.

Union of India & Ors. vs. Vartak Labour

Union. 2011 LLR 337 (S.C.)

This is the burden, workmen have to

discharge.

Rahimuddin and Others vs. Gossini Fashions

Ltd. 2011 LLR 824 (Del. HC)

Discharging duties of drafting

agreement, lease deeds, affidavits and

maintaining records can't be said to be of a

workman in nature. Employee was held

not be a workman.

Anita Mathur vs. Idea Cellular Ltd. 2011 LLR

1066 (Delhi HC)

Advocate / Legal advisor of the bank is

not a workman under ID Act.

Sonepat Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs.

Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal-cum-

Labour Court, Rohtak and Anr. 2011 III CLR

704 (P&H HC)

Branch officer of a finance company

can’t be held to be a workman.

Gruh Finance Limited vs. Pradip K. Shah. 2011

III CLR 708 (Guj. HC)

Personal financial consultant of a bank

appointed in lower management cadre will

not be a workman under ID Act. Dominant

nature of duties and responsibilities are to

be seen.

Vandana Joshi D/o. Mr. K.D. Joshi, Thane vs.

Standard Chartered Bank Ltd. 2011 LLR 126

(Bom. HC)

Assistant civil engineer and

administrative officer are not workman

under ID Act.

Exhibition Society, Exhibition Grounds,

Nampally, Hyderabad vs. Labour Court-II,

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

Mahendra Gajanan Trivedi vs. Bank of India

& Ors. 2011 LLR 1096 (Guj. HC)

Condition of refunding amount received

after VRS by workman is proper in order

to challenge VRS which was accepted

under duress.

Man Singh vs. Maruti Suzuki India Ltd. &

Another. 2011 LLR 1009 (SC)

If an application for voluntary

retirement is not withdrawn before

acceptance, its acceptance by the employer

will be valid.

Siddaiah vs. Management of Mandya

National Paper Mills Ltd., Belagula. 2011 LLR

1267 (Karn. HC)

Withdrawal of application for voluntary

retirement is permissible till the date the

same is to be effected in future.

Balaram Saghan Kshetra Samiti vs. Kantaben

Laljibhai Patel & 2 Ors. 2011 LLR 1251 (Guj. HC)

Workman

Even if the casual workers appointed for

six months on monthly break up to 30

years can’t claim permanency being

original appointment not in terms of the

process envisaged by the rules.

Union of India & Ors. vs. Vartak Labour

Union. 2011 LLR 337 (S.C.)

This is the burden, workmen have to

discharge.

Rahimuddin and Others vs. Gossini Fashions

Ltd. 2011 LLR 824 (Del. HC)

Discharging duties of drafting

agreement, lease deeds, affidavits and

maintaining records can't be said to be of a

workman in nature. Employee was held

not be a workman.

Anita Mathur vs. Idea Cellular Ltd. 2011 LLR

1066 (Delhi HC)

Advocate / Legal advisor of the bank is

not a workman under ID Act.

Sonepat Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs.

Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal-cum-

Labour Court, Rohtak and Anr. 2011 III CLR

704 (P&H HC)

Branch officer of a finance company

can’t be held to be a workman.

Gruh Finance Limited vs. Pradip K. Shah. 2011

III CLR 708 (Guj. HC)

Personal financial consultant of a bank

appointed in lower management cadre will

not be a workman under ID Act. Dominant

nature of duties and responsibilities are to

be seen.

Vandana Joshi D/o. Mr. K.D. Joshi, Thane vs.

Standard Chartered Bank Ltd. 2011 LLR 126

(Bom. HC)

Assistant civil engineer and

administrative officer are not workman

under ID Act.

Exhibition Society, Exhibition Grounds,

Nampally, Hyderabad vs. Labour Court-II,

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

Person can't be denied of benefit of a

workman under ID Act merely because he

was designated as apprentice or trainee. In

the absence of trainer to impart any

training to such persons, they will treated

as workman. Entitled for reinstatement.

Workmen of PMP Textiles, Coimbatore vs.

Management of PMP Textiles & Anr. 2011 LLR

731 (Mad. HC)

Test to determine whether a person is a

workman or not is to be decided by examining

the true nature of his dominant duties.

Superintending Engineer MSED Company Ltd.

vs. Sukhadev Ramchandra. CLR II 2011 P. 185

(Bom. HC)

'Balsevika' working on honorarium will

not be a workman under ID Act.

Devinder Kaur (Smt.) vs. Child Welfare

Council, Punjab & Ors. 2011 LLR 357 (P&H

HC): 2011 I CLR 42 (P&H HC)

To decide, whether a person is a

workman, his nature of dominant duties

and not the designation will be sole

criterion.

Superintending Engineer, Maharashtra State

Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd. (O&M),

Chandrapur and Anr. vs. Sukhdeo

Ramchandra Dhakite, Nagpur. 2011 LLR 662

(Bom. HC)

No relief to workmen when they failed to

establish the master-servant relationship.

Nampally, Hyderabad & Ors. 2011 LLR 532

(AP HC)

Part time junior executive discharging

the functions of loan documentation,

cheques disbursement making ledger

entries, preparing notices, statements,

maintaing EMI accounts, receiving

cheques and cash from customers are more

of administrative nature hence will not be

a workman under ID Act.

G.I.C. Housing Finance Ltd., Hyderabad and

Another vs. Presiding Officer, Labour Court-I,

A.P., Hyderabad and Another. 2011 LLR 801

(AP HC)

Design and development engineer

simply checking drawings prepared by

draftsman will be workman under ID Act.

Mayank Desai vs. Sayaji Iron & Engg. Co.

Ltd.& Anr. 2011 LLR 536 (Guj. HC)

Sub managers appointed under separate

contract of employment in the same mill

will not be workman under ID Act.

Management of Madura Coats Pvt. Ltd. and

Another vs. Presiding Officer, Labour Court,

Tirunelveli and Ors. 2011 LLR 486 (Mad. HC)

Whether the person is a workman or not,

this plea is to be raised before labour court.

Raising such objection in High Court will

not be of any help to management.

Aringer Anna Primary Agricultural Bank v.

Presiding Officer, Labour Court. LLN (4) 2010 P.

476 (Mad. HC)

BM

Ref.

: Labour Law Reporter,FLR, CLR, LLJ & APS Labour Digest

Business Manager

February 2012

55

Gratuity :

Provisions in relation to gratuity of

working journalists Act will prevail over the

provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act.

P. rajan Sandhi vs. Union of India & Anr. 2011

LLR 426 (S.C.)

When employee is allowed to retire, his

gratuity can't be forfeited merely beacuse

criminal proceedings were pending against

him.

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ashwin

Chimanlal Sheth & 2 Ors. 2011 LLR 66 (Guj. HC)

The person on fixed term employment

when worked for more than 5 years

because his contract was extended from

time to time, will be entitled for gratuity.

amount cannot be forfeited.

Vinod vs. State of Maharashtra and others.

2011 (128) FLR 618 (Bom. HC)

Once the authority passed order under

Gratuity Act, recovery against employer is

bound to be effected.

Jehangir Textile Mills vs. Sahebsingh

Chotesingh and Another. 2011 LLR 265 (Guj. HC)

When the employee was re-employed as

fresh badli worker, he will only be entitled to

gratuity for the period from the date of his

re-employment till the last date of working.

Phoenix Mills Ltd., Mumbai vs. Manohar

Arjun Rasal. 2011 LLR 382 (Bom. HC)

In the absence of any domestic enquiry

and order under sec. 4 (6)(a) and (b) of the

Payment of Gratuity Act, forfeiture of

gratuity would be illegal.

Maharashtra State Road Transport

Corporation, Mumbai vs. Maruti Ramchandra

Mastud. 2011 LLR 397 (Bom. HC)

Allowing 15% compound interest for

delay in making payment of gratuity by

employer is proper.

Hindustan Steel Works Construction Ltd. vs.

Suresh Kumar Chetal and Others. 2011 (128)

FLR 745 (Chhattisgarh HC)

Payment of Gratuity Act is applicable on

library. High Court can't direct the

authority under the Act to extend the

period of limitation beyond provided

under the Act.

Administrative Officer, T.M.S.S.M. Library and

Research Centre, Thanjavur vs. Appellate

Authority Under Payment of Gratuity Act (The

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

U.P. Bhumi Sudhar Nigam, Lucknow vs.

Appellate Authority and Others. 2011 LLR 164

(All. HC)

Personal allowance and special

compensatory allowance would not form

part of wages for the purpose of gratuity

under Payment of Gratuity Act.

State Bank of India, Goa vs. Laxmikant Vithal

Palekar & Ors. 2011 LLR 133 : 2011 (128) FLR

317 (Bom. HC)

Gratuity can't be withheld for not

vacating the quarter by employee.

Jehangir Textile Mills vs. Sahebsingh

Chotesingh. 2011 LLR 159 (Guj. HC)

Gratuity can't be withheld without

complying principles of natural justice.

Manmohan Prasad vs. H.P. State Small Scale

Industries and Export Corporation Ltd. 2011

LLR 177 (H.P. HC)

No forfeiture of gratuity without

termination for the specified misconduct.

M/s. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. vs. Union of

India. Through its Secretary and Others. 2011

LLR 203 (Jharkhand HC)

Casual worker putting in five years of

continuous service will be entitled to

Gratuity.

Pioneer Spinners, rep. by its General Manager

vs. Regional Labour Commissioner, Central,

Chennai. 2011 LLR 151 (Mad. HC)

In the absence of any specific finding

and charge against the petitioner, gratuity

Joint Commissioner of Labour) and Others.

2011 LLR 351 (Mad. HC)

In the absence of separate order of

forfeiture of gratuity, same can't be forfeited.

Manager Park Side Estate Nonsuch Post,

Coonoor vs. Appellate Authority under the

Payment of Gratuity Act/Joint Commissioner

of Labour, Coimbatore and Ors. 2011 LLR 416

(Mad. HC)

Gratuity cannot be denied to an

employee merely on the basis of the

undertaking signed by him that he will not

claim gratuity for the past period.

M. Selvadurai vs. Director Personnel, Block-I,

Corporate Office Neyveli Lignite Corporation

Limited & Ors. 2011 LLR 457 (Mad. HC)

Gratuity can not be forfeited for

misconduct of subversive of good

behaviour. But only for riotous and

disorderly behaviour and both

misconducts have different meaning

altogether.

Jaya Hind Industries Ltd., Akurdi, Pune vs.

Vilas Vithalrao Takale. 2011 LLR 638 (Bom. HC)

Gratuity with 8% interest rightly

awarded to legal heirs of the employee.

State of U.P. vs. Smt. Anwari Begum and

Another. 2011 (129) FLR 195 (All. HC)

Service of Badli worker during the years

in which he did not complete 240 days,

could not be considered for gratuity.

Vasantbhai Bhudarbhai vs. Manager, Arvind

Intex. LLJ II 2011 P. 145 (Guj. HC)

Business Manager

February 2012

39

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

The pendency of chargesheet against the

employee cannot constitute a sufficient

cause for non payment of interest on

delayed payment of gratuity by the

employer.

Vishal Singh Shekhawat vs. Rajasthan State

Ganganagar Sugar Mills Ltd. 2011 II 445

(Raj. HC)

Controlling Authority under the

Payment of Gratuity Act and not the High

Court will be the appropriate forum when

a person seeks to have Rs. 10 lakh after

receiving Rs. 3.5 lakh as gratuity.

P. S. Gupta vs. Union of India & Ors. 2011-II

CLR 70 (Del. HC)

Bank employee dismissed for financial

irregularities will not be entitled to

Gratuity.

Sabarkantha Dist. Central Co-op. Bank vs.

Ramanbhai M. Patel & Ors. 2011 CLR I P. 871

(Guj. HC)

Gratuity can be forfeited for violent and

riotous conduct of the employee.

Jaya Hind Industries Ltd. vs. Vilas V. Takale.

2011 CLR II P. 229 (Bom. HC)

Even if the workman retained the

company house illegally after retirement,

employer cannot withhold the gratuity on

this account. Gratuity cannot be attached

in execution of a decree of the court.

Binny Limited vs. The Asstt. Commissioner of

Labour (Authority under PG Act) & Ors. 2011

LLR 834 (Mad. HC)

In the absence of finding of quantified

loss caused due to the employee's

misconduct, gratuity cannot be forfeited

under sec. 4(6) of the Act.

Vinod Vinayak Jinturkar vs. State of

Maharashtra & Ors. 2011 LLJ II P. 659 (Bom. HC)

Employee of a registered society

appointed prior to the date of Notification

extending Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972,

will be entitled to Gratuity under the Act.

Indian Environmental Society vs. Dr. L.M.

Saxena. 2011 LLJ II P. 790. (Del. HC)

When official accomodation was not

vacated after retirement, it was proper to

adjust penal rent from retirement dues.

Smt. Asha Saxena (Dead) by LRs. vs. U.P. State

Electricity Board and Others. 2011 LLR 924

(Allahabad HC)

Teachers are entitled to get gratuity

under the Act.

Mahendra Singh Chhabra vs. Appellate

Authority, Payment of Gratuity Act, Indore and

Another. 2011 LLR 980 (MP HC)

Teachers will be entitled to gratuity

from the date of joining and not from the

date of the amendment effected in the Act

i.e. 3.4.97.

Ananta Vishwanathan (Mrs.) vs. Shri

Narayana Guru High School & Ors. 2011 LLR

995 (Bom. HC)

Employer can't be allowed to stall the

claim of gratuity by indulging in

litigation. Employer liable to pay gratuity

with 15% compound interest.

Hindustan Steel Works Construction Ltd. vs.

Suresh Kumar Chetal and Others. 2011 (3) LLN

163 (Chhattisgarh HC)

Gratuity claim after 5 years of VRS that

too on fixed personal and compensatory

allowance was not maintainable.

State Bank of India vs. Shri Laxmikant Vithal

Palekar. 2011 (3) LLN 139 (Bom. HC)

Gratuity can’t be claimed under ID Act.

VST Industries Ltd. vs. Presiding Officer,

Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court,

Godavarikhani, Karimnagar District and

Others. 2011 LLR 1170 (AP HC)

An order of the Controlling Authority

under the Payment of Gratuity Act allowing

claim for gratuity cannot be challenged

and/or decided in a writ petition.

M/s. Ranbeer Automobiles and Another vs.

State of West Bengal. 2011 LLR 1188 (Cal. HC)

Appeal against the order of controlling

authority after maximum limit of 120 days

will not be maintenable.

Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation vs. Sunderben

Chhanabhai Baraiya Legal heirs of late

Chhanabhai & 2 Ors. 2011 LLR 1250 (Guj. HC)

No Work-No Pay

If the workmen are not allowed to work

by the employer, the principle "no work no

pay" will not apply.

Panipat Co-op. Sugar Mills Ltd. vs. Presiding

Officer, Labour Court & Ors. CLR II 2011 P. 292

(P&H HC)

Over time

When a worker is provided with

accommodation, travelling allowance and

city compensatory allowance are not

universally paid to each and every

employee, such allowances are not required

U.P. State Road Transport Corporation vs.

Appellate Authority under Payment of Wages

Act, Mau and Others. 2011 LLR 629 (All. HC)

Construction of residential house

activity will be covered under the Payment

of Wages Act.

Smt. Shashi Sharma vs. The Labour-cum-

Conciliation Officer & Anr. 2011 LLR 841

(P&H HC)

Challenging order of the employer

proposing to make deduction of 8 days'

wages of the striking workers under

article 226 of Constitution of India will

not be appropriate since the appropriate

forum has been provided under the

Payment of Wages Act, 1936.

Hind Khadan Mazdoor Federation vs. Coal India

Ltd. and Others. 2011 (130) FLR 125 (MP HC)

Five times penalty instead of ten times

for non payment of leave wages would be

proper keeping in view the financial

difficulties of the organization.

Akola Zillah Dudh Utpadak Sangh Sahakari

Sansthanacha Sangh Ltd., Akola vs. Sheshrao

Ramchandra Mhasaye. 2011 LLR 1018 (Bom. HC)

No writ against order of authority under

Payment of Wages Act.

Ramala Sahkari Chini Mills Limited, Meerut

vs. Authority under Payment of Wages Act and

Others. 2011 LLR 1102 (All. HC)

Denial of wages to data entry operators

reverted to the post of conductors for the

period from the date of reversion to date

on which the workmen were restored to

their original position will be illegal.

From The Court Room Important Labour Judgments 2011

to be included for the purpose of over time

payment under ‘ordinary rate of wages’ as

per sec. 59(1) and (2) of Factories Act.

Jossie vs. Flag Officers Commanding-in-Chief.

2011 LLR 1168 (Kerala HC)
KVJ Raghunath ✓
KVJ Raghunath
✓ Article Link Copied to Clipboard!